7 Best Indestructible Toys for Aggressive Chewers in 2024

Most people chalk a chewing dog up to teething; after all, puppies are known for biting whatever they can get their paws on in order to soothe the irritation of incoming teeth. While it’s true that puppies are some of the most aggressive chewers, there are still adult dogs who love to chew as well. When the aggressive chewing keeps going from six months to six years, dog owners alike have to wonder if there’s a good solution that won’t break the bank.

Chewy Online Dog Supplies

35% Off at Chewy.com

+ Free Shipping

Save Now

Luckily, we’ve got the answers. Chew toys come in all different shapes and sizes, but they all have one common goal: to keep your dog happy and keep him from chewing on your personal possessions. The specific reason why your dog wants to chew may vary. As we mentioned earlier, if you’re raising a young puppy, your pal is likely chewing to alleviate the pain of growing new teeth.

Older dogs chew for other reasons, like the fact that they just find it fun and entertaining. The positive association that your dog has with chewing likely came from puppyhood when you encouraged them to chew on their favorite toy and not the corner of your couch. It probably relaxes them as a comforting thing. Plus, it keeps them busy.

Your dog may also be searching for some kind of mental stimulation. If you find your dog tends to chew your household objects while you’re out of the house, he might be bored or stressed. Chew toys offer a positive alternative that will keep him happy and busy and keep your furniture out of harm’s way. Below, we’ve got some in-depth information about the best indestructible toys for aggressive chewers:

What to Look for in a Good Indestructible Toy for Aggressive Chewers

To a dog, chewing is essential and often non-negotiable. That’s why it’s best to supplement their habit rather than trying to eliminate it altogether. So what makes a good indestructible toy? Your first priority should always be your dog’s safety. When it comes to chew toys, this means finding something that’s not toxic, that won’t break apart in sharp pieces, and that isn’t small enough for them to accidentally swallow. Every dog is different, so it helps to take notice of how they use the toys you currently have for them.

An aggressive chewer is likely one who actively destroys toys, so you can take note of the types of toys he’s already torn through without hesitation. Keeping your dog’s safety and personality in mind, the next best quality of a good indestructible toy for aggressive chewers is durability. This one is pretty obvious, as our goal here is to find toys that will last through some vigorous chomping.

Though some chew toys are hard, it’s good to find toys that have a little bit of give to them. Think of thick rubber toys. Not only are these kinds of toys soothing for teething puppies, but they’re more entertaining for most dogs. You should also keep your eye out for any flavors or coatings, including with the chew toys.

It’s pretty common to find toys at pet stores that have tastes to make them more appealing to dogs, but some pups with more sensitive stomachs could react poorly to these coatings. A good chew toy is also easy to clean. If you get lucky, your newest chew toy for your aggressive chewer may very well become your dog’s new best friend. If that’s the case, he’s going to take it everywhere, so it’s nice to be able to toss it in the dishwasher.

Finally, the best chew toys are entertaining! Fun colors, shapes, and textures can keep a puppy occupied for hours on end. Some chew toys come attached to ropes, while others have pockets for hidden treats.

Overall Best Indestructible Toys for Aggressive Chewers

Adult dogs who are aggressive chewers are much more likely to easily tear a toy apart with their fully developed muscles, sharper focus, and mature teeth. The following products are awesome choices for aggressive chewers, beginning with our pick for best overall.

KONG Classic Dog Toy

Best Overall

If there’s any dog toy brand that’s considered reliable, it’s gotta be KONG. Because this brand is known for its durable dog toys, we knew it had to make an appearance on the top of our list of toys for aggressive chewers.

The classic KONG toy is a uniquely shaped rubber toy with a super durable, specialized formula. Even the toughest chewers can’t tear through this sturdy toy. It’s great for some high-quality chewing that will minimize boredom, stress, and even separation anxiety.

The rounded pyramid-like shape is actually hollow with thick walls, so you can stuff it with things like cheese, peanut butter, or your pup’s favorite treats. This same shape is also super fun for fetch, as the uneven curves offer an unpredictable bounce.

Benebone Bacon Flavor Wishbone

The Benebone Wishbone is a sturdy, durable, bacon-flavored chew toy that’s perfect for medium breeds with aggressive chewing habits. This USA-sourced product promises nothing but high-quality materials, from the durable nylon to the real bacon flavoring.

The ends of this chew toy mimic the shapes of a real bone, while the Y-shape makes it easy for your dog to get a good grip and comfortably chew for as long as they want. Your dog will love this toy so much that he’ll ignore your favorite pair of shoes.

As an added bonus, the all-natural bacon flavor doesn’t sit on top as a coating like other toys; it’s actually infused throughout the whole thing.

Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball 

We’re going to go ahead and assume that your aggressive chewer is also a big lover of playtime. Since those things tend to go hand-in-hand in terms of doggy personalities, we love a product that offers a dual purpose.

The Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball is like your standard tennis ball with a massive upgrade. The ball is made entirely of extra-thick rubber with a solid core, making it utterly indestructible for even the toughest of chewers.

While your dog will love to sit and chew on this high-quality toy, he’ll also love to play fetch with it. It’s built to last, provides a gripping surface for grabbing and catching, offers excellent visibility for your dog, and even floats in water. What more could Fido want?

Starmark Treat Dispensing Chew Ball

When boredom becomes destructive and chewing gets out of hand, the Starmark Treat Dispensing Chew Ball can become a real lifesaver. This large, rubber ball has an innovative design that makes it super durable, yet soft in your dog’s mouth.

The flexible rubber engages your dog, drawing focus to its unique texture and away from your furniture or shoes. It boasts a small hole on one end for you to fill it with treats or even your dog’s meals, making it attractive and functional.

Free of latex, vinyl, and phthalates, this toy is safe for your pup and even helps to nurture your dog’s natural tendency towards hunting. Plus, any kind of ball leaves room for fun games of fetch.

Overall Best Indestructible Toys for Aggressive Chewers for Puppies

While older dogs might chew just as much, puppies have special needs as far as chewing goes. In order to better help you with puppies who might be teething or experience gum soreness, we’ve selected a few of the best indestructible toys for aggressive chewing puppies, starting with our best overall.

KONG Puppy Teething Stick

Best Overall 

A trusted name in puppy and adult dog products alike, KONG is known for its durability and toughness. The KONG Puppy Teething Stick is an ideal choice for teething puppies who just can’t stop chewing.

The shape and size of the teething stick are the perfect fit for a puppy’s small mouth and teeth. Made from a soft rubber formula, puppies will love to sink their teeth into the bouncy surface, soothing their sore gums and keeping them from chewing on your prized possessions.

The innovative ridges around the chew toy help to gently clean teeth and gums along the way, and the hollowed-out center is great for hiding treats to keep your pup occupied for hours. It’s a simple toy that goes a long way for heavy chewers.

Nylabone Puppy Teething X Bone

Your puppy is already trying to get their footing, from running and jumping to learning to climb stairs, so it’s only fair that their toys are easy to grip with their clumsy paws. The Nylabone Puppy Teething X Bone is specially designed in the shape of an X, which is a paw-friendly design.

It also features tons of different bumps and ridges around the natural bone-shaped ends, delivering unique textures to grab your puppy’s ever-changing attention span.

The durable nylon is sure to outlast even the heaviest of chewers. While the textures are great for fun, they are also functional in that they help promote dental health and massage the gums for relief from teething.

JW Pet Chompion Dog Toy

Though this toy is perfectly well-suited for aggressive chewing adult dogs, it’s also perfect for teething puppies as well. The JW Pet Chompion Dog Toy is a highly durable, fun-shaped toy that delivers endless hours of chewing with fun textures.

The various bumps and nubs allow for improved dental health, while also soothing sore and aching gums to alleviate teething woes. Its multipurpose design is great for chewing, fetch, and even tug of war.

You can get this toy in lightweight, medium, or heavyweight sizes, so you can match your dog’s size and chewing habits. For those heavy chewers, the heavyweight size is an awesome choice. Plus, they’ll love the taste of the infused vanilla extract.

Tips for Playing with Your Indestructible Toy for Aggressive Chewers

Aggressive chewers need special attention. Otherwise, you’ll be looking at ruined shows, gnawed furniture, and destroyed pillows. Follow these tips to make sure both you and your aggressive chewer are happy campers:

  1.  Look for toys with additional features to catch your dog’s attention, i.e., squeakers, scents, and flavors.
  2. To get your puppy interested in a new toy, play with them instead of simply handing it to them and walking away.
  3.  Remember to praise your dog for chewing on his chew toy! Positive reinforcement goes a long way, and he’ll be more likely to choose the toy over your couch cushions next time.
  4. Use toys to redirect your puppy from chewing on your household items. Rather than scolding her, show her a chew toy instead.

When we spot our aggressive chewers taking their frustration out on our personal items, we can be tempted to yell and punish. However, staying positive and offering up alternative solutions can have a better impact on your dog’s overall behavior.

Frequently Asked Questions

Owners of aggressive chewing dogs often have the same kinds of questions, so we’ve listed a few FAQs for you to check out for more information.

Can my dog break his teeth on chew toys?

Though dogs are certainly bigger chewers than people are, their teeth actually only have a third of the enamel thickness that humans do. Plus, they chew three times harder. That being said, while people have the capacity to measure how carefully and hard we chew, dogs don’t showcase that same care. Harder treats like bone, antlers, and hooves have the potential to crack a dog’s teeth.

Though the previously listed items are trendy among dog owners, the best rule of thumb is to only buy chew toys that you can indent with your fingernail. If you press down on a toy with your thumbnail and it doesn’t give at all, it could harm your dog’s teeth, especially if they’re an aggressive chewer.

Are chew toys dishwasher safe?

Most dog chew toys are washable in the dishwasher, but only if they’re a sturdy rubber material. Some chew toys feature fabric or fragile rubber that could be ruined with water or melt in too much heat. If your toy is dishwasher safe, it will likely say so on the packaging, as that’s a strong selling point for a lot of pet owners. If it doesn’t say dishwasher safe, err on the side of caution and wash the toy by hand.

How do I know if my dog has the wrong size chew toy?

Spotting the wrong size chew toy for your dog can range from simple to very serious. For starters, you can tell a toy is too big if you see your little puppy fail to even get her mouth around it. A chew toy isn’t beneficial to a teething puppy if she can’t bite down with her gums. On the more severe end, if the toy is small enough for your dog to swallow it whole, it’s definitely too small. Consuming an entire toy can be extremely dangerous. If you’re unsure where a chew toy has gone, check for signs of blood, vomiting, diarrhea, loss of appetite, or loss of energy in your pup. If you see these signs, call your vet immediately.


Aggressive chewers don’t mean any harm, but their bad habits can undoubtedly cause some hefty damage. To protect your home and keep your puppy happy, try giving them one of the high-quality, top-rated toys we’ve talked about today.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *